Water Based Thickeners
- The easiest way to add xanthan gum to the water phase of your formulations is to first disperse the gum into a water-miscible solvent like propanediol, butylene glycol, or glycerin before adding to water.
- Use combinations of thickeners that work by different mechanisms to achieve maximum viscosity using the least amount of material. Examples include combining swellable polymers with soluble polymers, or clays with swellable or soluble polymers.
- Oil-in-water emulsions thickened using swellable polymers like carbomers and acrylate copolymers can sometimes be difficult to pick up and spread on skin due to their salt sensitivity. Adding .1-.2% xanthan gum can significantly improve pickup and product spreadability.
- Adding swellable- and soluble-polymers to the oil phase of oil-in-water emulsions prior to emulsification can frequently improve the quality of the emulsion. The technique works well for neutralized swellable-polymer powders or dispersions and soluble-polymers like xanthan gum.
- Use surface-treated easy-to-disperse grades of powdered carbomers and acrylate copolymers for easier incorporation into water.
- The best thickener to formulate high alcohol (60-90%) sanitizer formulations is acrylates/C10-30 alkyl acrylate crosspolymer neutralized using triisopropanolamine or tetrahydroxypropyl ethylenediamine.
- The most efficient salt-stable all-natural-based thickening system is a mixture of konjac glucomannan (amorphophallus konjac root extract) and xanthan gum.
Oil-in-water emulsions
- When formulating thin, stable, sprayable oil-in-water emulsions, use thickener combinations that have a high yield value or resting viscosity. Examples include magnesium aluminum silicate, sodium magnesium fluorosilicate or microcrystalline cellulose combined with xanthan gum or carboxymethyl cellulose.
- Always add salts after emulsification to lamellar gel network-based formulations for maximum viscosity and stability. Ideally below the phase transition temperature (<45C).
- Adding low levels of soluble- or swellable-polymers to lamellar gel network-based formulations can reduce the graininess commonly seen in freeze/thaw stability samples.
- Using a 60% or 90% mono glyceryl stearate in oil-in-water emulsions will normally give you a better emulsion and skin feel than using a conventional 35-40% mono glyceryl stearate.
- A natural based oil-in-water lamellar gel network-based emulsion with good long-term stability is stearyl alcohol 2%, glyceryl stearate (60% mono) 2%, and triglyceryl stearate 1%.
Water-in-oil emulsions
- Adding zinc sulfate can help stabilize water-in-oil emulsions and significantly reduce the preservative level in the formulation. Chelating agents should not be used in this application. Currently, most water-in-oil emulsions use sodium chloride or magnesium sulfate as stabilizers.
- Adding low levels of soluble- or water-swellable-polymers to the water phase of water-in-oil emulsions can significantly improve their freeze/thaw stability.
- Over shearing water-in-oil emulsions can cause a viscosity decrease over time.
Solubilizing oils into water
- When solubilizing fragrances into water start by using 5 parts of active solubilizer for every part of fragrance. If successful, reduce the solubilizer to the point of failure. This will establish the working range of the solubilizer.
- Polar oils, like fragrances, are significantly easier to solubilize than most cosmetic emollients. It can take as much as 15-20 parts of solubilizer for each part oil compared to 3-5 parts for most fragrances.
- Good natural based solubilizers include polyglyceryl 10 oleate and sorbitan oleate decylglucoside crosspolymer.
Emollients
Use emollients in formulations that have good skin feel and clinically proven skin effects. Examples of natural emollients include squalane, and jojoba oil. Others to consider include isostearyl isostearate, C12/13 lactate, myristyl lactate, and isosorbide dicaprylate.
For more information, please continue to Part Two
UL Prospector has more than 30,000 personal care and cosmetics materials to help you formulate most effectively! Advanced tools are also available for those who need regulatory information and natural product certifications with a premium membership.
The views, opinions and technical analyses presented here are those of the author or advertiser, and are not necessarily those of ULProspector.com or UL Solutions. The appearance of this content in the UL Prospector Knowledge Center does not constitute an endorsement by UL Solutions or its affiliates.
All content is subject to copyright and may not be reproduced without prior authorization from UL Solutions or the content author.
The content has been made available for informational and educational purposes only. While the editors of this site may verify the accuracy of its content from time to time, we assume no responsibility for errors made by the author, editorial staff or any other contributor.
UL Solutions does not make any representations or warranties with respect to the accuracy, applicability, fitness or completeness of the content. UL Solutions does not warrant the performance, effectiveness or applicability of sites listed or linked to in any content.
Very good compendium of useful formulating tips there George. Most I knew but others not so much. Could be a good SCC Quiz someday perhaps? Love the comment regarding “Hold the chelating agent” when formulating with multivalent metal salts. Amazing how many times I’ve seen that miscue in published formulations. Regarding the thickening of alcohol hand sanitizers: while Ultrez-21 (C10-30 alkyl acrylate crosspolymer) rocks, Rapidgel EZ1 (AMP-acrylate/vinyl isodecanoate crosspolymer) rocks even more. You just drop the liquid right into the batch and voila: alcohol gelled in minutes.
Can you provide the suppliers for:
A natural based oil-in-water lamellar gel network-based emulsion with good long-term stability is stearyl alcohol 2%, glyceryl stearate (60% mono) 2%, and triglyceryl stearate 1%.
Nicholas, we would recommend searching ULProspector.com for the ingredients you need. You can utilize the site to contact the suppliers for various materials if you have additional questions that the technical details provided don’t answer.
Thanks for reading!
Rita
Why chelating agents should not be used to aid in stabilization of water-in-oil emultions?
Dear Alberto,
Chelating agents help preserve the product. If you use Magnesium Sulfate to stabilize the emulsion, the chelating agent will be inactivated due to reacting with the chelating agent. If you use Sodium Chloride to stabilize the emulsion you will not have this problem. A better idea is to use Zinc Sulfate to stabilize the emulsion and help preserve the formulation. This eliminates the need for the chelating agent.
Thanks for reading!
George
I didn’t know that you could add zinc sulfate to metal. I need new pipes imported into our basement. I’ll have to consider getting a steel framework set up paired with aluminum.